Chapter Thirty-Two - The Weight of Choice



The Acadia stone chapel sat on the quieter edge of the village, open to anyone who needed the space. Lantern light filtered through narrow windows. Nate slipped in quietly and sat in the back row—he wasn’t on official Warden business; today he was there just like the other villagers in the chapel, looking for answers from anywhere he could get them.

Spiritual Guide Sebastian Shore was facilitating the discussion. “Right then. Fate. Can Fate and Free Will exist beside one another? Does Fate negate Free Will? If you’re reading a novel, the characters in them make decisions, but they are guided by the author who created the story—something that is outside or above their established world. Does that mean we are in the same situation? To us, it may seem like free will. But beyond the veil, is it all scripted by an all-powerful entity?”

“Free will is just the ability to choose for oneself what one does,” said a witch named Michelle. “It doesn’t free one from the consequences and fallout of those choices. It just lets you make those choices in the first place.”

Another witch arrived late, but her brow lifted. “Why does it matter if it feels the same to us if we have it or not?” Nicola asked. “It’s like arguing if the sky is blue. Feels like a pointless argument.”

Nate listened to the discussion, not sure what to add to the conversation, so he merely stayed quiet and sat beside Ethan, a Taurus wizard who nodded to him.

“Welcome in, man. We’re discussing free will today. Nothing serious,” he smirked, making Nate chuckle in response.

“Yeah, that is why I do not lose sleep over it,” Daphne glanced over at Nicola. “To us, it is all the same. Focus on making wiser choices.”

“Precisely,” grinned Sebastian. “Consequences are what make free will free; to make choices, but also to make mistakes. And hopefully learn from them. Or maybe it is all a test. There are many who believe that our existence is merely a test, and you keep repeating it until you learn what you need to attain enlightenment and ascend.” He looked around and said, “Questioning is how we learn. Learning is how we grow. It is how we survive.”

Nicola nodded. “You keep trying for the best and either it was written for you like that and you are a good character in someone’s sick story, or it was not, and then you are just getting better. Win-win. The more important question is how to tell what decisions are the good ones.”

“The whole thing feels like a paradox,” Avalon Gray pointed out. “You are told when something bad happens that it was ‘Fate’, or that it was part of the creator’s plan. But if we actually have free will, then it would be the consequences of a choice stemming from free will. So which one is it?”

“Both?” Nate asked, somewhat unhelpfully, with a smirk to the Guide.

“Precisely!” Sebastian beamed at Nicola. “How do we tell what decisions are good, and which are not? Outcomes, past experiences; our own and others. But how do we find out about these past experiences when they are not our own? Through discourse, sharing stories... Community. And you cannot have a community unless you share opinions, ask questions, and working together.”

“If there is no real ability to turn away from the easy path, or the expected one,” Nate stated, “then it is just performance and programming. Not love, not duty, not anything that costs.”

“Well said,” Sebastian smiled at him. “We seem to be out of time. Thank you all for an enlightening discussion.”

As they rose to filter out, Nate saw Tyra heading out but didn’t follow this time. He knew that he was playing with fire regarding her, but he didn’t care. Though it might be prudent to create some space between them...

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Bayou Files

Chapter Three - Blue Moon Rites

Chapter Two - The Warden’s Watch